The Dos and Don'ts of Personalization in Social Media Marketing

January 15, 2024

Personalized social media content is not merely a trend, but a strategic approach that allows brands to connect with their audience on a more human level. However, to truly maximize the effectiveness of personalized engagement — especially on Meta platforms like Facebook and Instagram — marketers must strike a delicate balance between getting their message across and doing it without compromising authenticity or crossing boundaries. 

When used properly, personalization can be a powerful tool for engaging your audience. Here’s a rundown of the dos and don’ts of personalized social media engagement to help you establish more meaningful connections while driving business growth and increasing brand awareness. 

The dos

To make sure your personalized Instagram and Facebook content is effective, consider using these tips to woo your audience. 

1. Use Instagram Insights to create highly targeted audiences

Instagram Insights is a goldmine for marketing data. You’ll find everything you need about your audience, from who your followers are to the content they engage with the most, and what times your audience is most active. With all this data at your fingertips, you can create tailored audience segments based on specific interests, behaviors, or engagement levels to ensure your marketing campaigns are effective.

2. Use Facebook Dynamic Ads and Instagram Shopping

Facebook Dynamic Ads dynamically display products or services to users who have shown interest in them, allowing for personalized recommendations based on their browsing history or previous interactions. 

Similarly, Instagram Shopping integrates seamlessly with organic content, enabling your business to tag products in posts and stories, providing a direct shopping experience within the platform. Together, these features not only enhance the user experience by delivering relevant and personalized content but also streamline the path to purchase and improve conversion rates.

3. Try retargeting using the Facebook Pixel and Instagram Pixel

Employing advanced retargeting strategies such as Facebook Pixel and Instagram Pixel to track user interactions and behavior on your website or app can significantly bolster your personalized social media engagement efforts. Because both tracking tools enable you to gather data on user behavior, it’s easier to retarget users with personalized content based on their previous actions, preferences, or abandoned carts. It also allows you to create a more personalized and relevant experience for users, reminding them of products they've shown interest in, thereby nurturing a more meaningful connection between your brand and audience.

4. Integrate AI-powered chatbots into your Facebook Messenger and Instagram Direct Messages

AI-powered chatbots can use machine learning algorithms to understand user queries, preferences, and behaviors, delivering highly personalized responses and recommendations. Facebook and Instagram bots in particular enable real-time, automated interactions with users, offering personalized assistance, recommendations, and support round the clock. 

These chatbots deliver tailored responses and suggestions, mimicking human interactions. Integrating AI-powered chatbots not only expedites customer service but also allows for personalized product recommendations, content delivery, and even transactional assistance. In addition, these chatbots continuously learn from interactions, refining their responses and recommendations over time, ensuring a seamless and personalized experience for users. Using this technology, you can actively engage with users, which demonstrates your commitment to your audience's needs and concerns.

5. Take advantage of Instagram’s Collab feature

One of Instagram’s most recent new features, Collab, allows marketers to co-author content with a collaborator, which can multiply engagement and reach and can increase followers. Consider leveraging this feature to collaborate with industry leaders, influencers, and brand partners so that when collab posts show up in your followers’ feeds, you can garner higher engagement.

6. Always respect privacy and boundaries

Eight out of 10 consumers are worried about data privacy. Considering the vast array of accessible data, it's crucial to use personal information ethically and transparently. Before using personal information, always ask for consent and explain how you plan to use the data. 

Image Source

Upholding user privacy instills confidence in customers that their information is handled responsibly, safeguarding against potential breaches or misuse. While there is a fine line between tailored content and intrusion, respecting boundaries enhances the user experience without making individuals feel exposed or uncomfortable. It also helps your business adhere to legal and ethical standards.

7. Embrace the 80/20 rule

Users don’t log in to their social media accounts to see ads. In fact, statistics reveal that approximately 47% use it to keep in touch with friends and family, while 36% find it to be a good way to spend their free time. If you want to really capture your audience’s attention, focus 80% of your content on providing value, education, entertainment, or addressing tailored audience needs. Reserve the remaining 20% for promotional or branded content to create a sense of exclusivity.

When users’ social media accounts become inundated with endless promotional messages, they’ll start to tune you out. However, if you dedicate the majority of efforts towards offering meaningful, tailored content that resonates with your audience, not only will you captivate your audience and foster authentic connections, but you’ll also maximize revenue.

Top reported reasons for using social media, Source

8. Leverage through-channel marketing automation (TCMA)

By providing a holistic view of your audience's behaviors, preferences, and interactions across different channels, through-channel marketing automation (TCMA) enables you to orchestrate personalized campaign content. It ensures that each interaction resonates with the specific interests and needs of different audience segments. 

Through-channel marketing automation also facilitates precise scheduling and deployment of content, optimizing the timing and frequency of posts and ads to maximize engagement and impact. Additionally, it streamlines workflows, allowing you to allocate resources more efficiently and focus on refining strategies to foster brand loyalty and more meaningful connections across Facebook and Instagram.

The don'ts

Customized marketing is powerful, but using it the wrong way can frustrate your audience. To avoid potential pitfalls, steer clear of these personalization practices. 

1. Don’t overuse automation

While automation can streamline processes, excessive reliance on automated responses or messages can come off as impersonal. Avoid using automation to replace genuine human interaction entirely. Instead, aim to blend automation intelligently within human-led interactions to enhance efficiency while maintaining a personalized touch. Doing so will ensure a balanced and authentic customer experience.

2. Don’t neglect negative feedback

Ignoring negative comments or feedback can harm your brand reputation. Address criticism respectfully, offering solutions or clarifications publicly or privately, based on the situation. Acknowledging and addressing negative feedback not only exhibits empathy, but also strengthens trust with your audience by showcasing a willingness to learn, evolve, and prioritize the needs of your customers.

3. Don’t assume personal details

Avoid making assumptions based on limited personal information. Personalization should be based on verified data or user-provided information rather than assumptions that might be inaccurate or offensive. Rather than relying on stereotypes or generalizations, personalization should cater to individual preferences. Aim to treat each user uniquely and definitely don’t use data that wasn’t voluntarily provided. 

4. Don’t spam or overwhelm users

Bombarding users with excessive messages, notifications, or content can be overwhelming and push them away. Being too overbearing can be a huge turn-off for consumers and cause them to disengage or unsubscribe from your channels altogether. By implementing a frequency cap on ads you can strike a good balance between personalized targeting and avoiding audience saturation. With the right frequency, you’ll be able to retain interest while keeping content fresh and respecting your audience's tolerance for advertising content.

5. Don’t engage in controversial topics without caution

While personalization aims for connection, avoid engaging in controversial or sensitive topics without a thoughtful approach. Such discussions may alienate segments of your audience or create conflicts. Assess whether the topic aligns with the brand's values and if the discussion will add genuine value or positively contribute to the audience's experience. A thoughtful approach that respects diverse viewpoints and avoids inflammatory rhetoric is essential to maintain a harmonious and inclusive community within your audience.

6. Don’t neglect monitoring and adjusting

Regularly monitoring the effectiveness of personalized engagement strategies is fundamental to optimizing and enhancing your approach. Your ongoing evaluation should involve tracking various metrics, including user engagement rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, sentiment analysis, and more. 

Also be sure to gather feedback from users through surveys, comments, or direct messages to obtain invaluable qualitative data that will help you understand audience perceptions and preferences. By meticulously assessing these indicators, you can identify patterns, pinpoint successful strategies, and recognize areas needing improvement and adjust accordingly.

Use MarinOne to boost personalized social media engagement

Your primary aim on social media should be to deliver an exceptional experience tailored specifically to your target audience. Customizing each piece of content your audience encounters to align with their unique interests and preferences is crucial. When you do, your business will reap the rewards of heightened engagement and increased customer satisfaction, creating a mutually beneficial scenario.

With MarinOne’s all-in-one platform, marketers can delve into detailed audience segmentation, allowing for precise targeting based on demographics, behaviors, and preferences. Our platform facilitates the seamless integration of data from various sources, providing invaluable insights into audience interactions across different channels. Using our advanced analytics, marketers can optimize content strategies, identify trends, and tailor their social media content to resonate deeply with specific audience segments.

Whether through content scheduling, A/B testing, or audience-centric optimizations, MarinOne equips marketers with the necessary tools to create compelling, personalized social media content that fosters stronger connections and drives meaningful engagement with their target audience.

Are you ready to start generating personalized social media content for your audience? Sign up for a free trial today.

Lauren Neels

Marin Software
By submitting this form, I am agreeing to Marin’s privacy policy.

See why brands have relied on Marin to manage over $48 billion in spend