Dynamic Search Ads (DSA) to Performance Max (PMax) Campaigns: The Evolution and Benefits

December 11, 2023

Dynamic Search Ads (DSA) are an advanced ad format that uses website content to craft ad headlines and landing pages. These automatically generated ads align with user searches related to the website, resulting in efficient ad creation and increased relevance and coverage.

In contrast, Performance Max (PMax) campaigns have only recently started to make an impact compared to DSA. Unlike DSAs focused on Search Network, PMax strategies distribute ads across the Google network, including Search, Display, YouTube, Discover. This broader reach enables more conversion opportunities.

Despite advertisers being able to provide multiple assets for the new placement, by developing ad assets, like images and headlines, the lack of actual placement control is what most marketers are concerned about.

Understanding Dynamic Search Ads

Dynamic Search Ads (DSA) have transformed how advertisers reach their target audience. By scanning website content to ascertain the relevance of each page to different search queries, DSAs deliver targeted ads to match user searches. This tactic helps drive higher click-through rates and conversions.

Image Source

DSA Campaigns: A New Advertising Approach

With the ability to harness queries not covered by keywords in Advertiser’s accounts, DSAs offer valuable insights into user behavior. These insights assist in refining Pay-Per-Click campaigns, leading to better ad performance and increased return on investment.

Targeting with Precision

DSAs offer the flexibility to target specific categories on a website. This ensures ads align with user searches, allowing businesses to concentrate their advertising efforts on high-value categories, leading to more efficient use of their budget.

Keyword Concepts Discovery through DSAs

By analyzing search queries that triggered the DSAs, advertisers can identify new keywords for other campaigns. This strategy helps in expanding campaign reach and capturing more customers.

Overall DSAs have become a critical tool for advertisers, enabling them to reach their target audience more effectively and achieve improved ad performance and higher ROI. Despite the rise of PMax campaigns, the value of DSAs remains high.

Embracing PMax Campaigns

The world of digital advertising is witnessing a shift in the performance of Dynamic Search Ads. DSAs, despite offering value,are likely to be phased out by Google and incorporated into Performance Max campaigns. Advertisers are encouraged to favor PMax for its broader reach and increased number of ad assets.

Image Source

Challenges with DSA Performance

DSAs, once successful, are now experiencing a performance dip. They efficiently delivered targeted ads but lacked additional control. The automated ad creation process, based on website content and user searches, left little room for advertisers to shape the ad content, becoming a major limitation.

Advantages of PMax Campaigns

PMax campaigns are emerging as an alternative to DSAs. PMax campaigns distribute ads across various Google networks, including Search, Display, YouTube, Discover, etc. This broad reach opens up more opportunities for conversions. Additionally, PMax campaigns allow advertisers to participate in the ad creation process by providing multiple assets not available on DSAs (Videos & images for example).

Transitioning to PMax Campaigns

Transitioning from DSAs to PMax campaigns presents challenges. PMax campaigns, while providing more assets and reach, demand active involvement from advertisers. This includes developing ad assets like images and headlines. This process can be time-consuming and requires understanding the various Google networks and their audiences.

Considerations in the Transition

Switching from DSAs to PMax campaigns involves trade-offs. Advertisers may lose some automation benefits DSAs offer, like automatic ad creation based on website content and user searches. However, the increased ad assets provided can lead to more strategic ad placement and improved performance. The ability to distribute ads across multiple Google networks broadens reach, increasing conversion opportunities. While the transition involves compromises, the advantages of PMax campaigns often surpass the hurdles.

Control Shifts in Advertising Campaigns

Transitioning from Dynamic Search Ads (DSAs) to Performance Max (PMax) campaigns also involves a shift in control and a decrease in automation. DSAs, which auto-create ads based on website content, offer a passive role for advertisers but limit ad shaping options.

 PMax campaigns, however, provide more Ad Assets like images and headlines, giving advertisers more control over the final product for strategic ad placement and improved performance. However, the actual ads shown are out of the advertiser's control. 

The shift to PMax reduces automation, requiring more advertiser involvement in ad creation for different Google networks. While this demands more effort, it offers more targeted and effective advertising opportunities.

Microsoft Rolls Out Performance Max

Microsoft's Dynamic Search Ads

Microsoft, like Google, provides a Dynamic Search Ads (DSA) option for advertisers. Microsoft's DSAs analyze your website content and generate ads aligning with user queries, a function that Google's DSAs also perform. This automated process allows advertisers to deliver targeted ads efficiently, thus enhancing their campaign relevance and coverage.

Furthermore, DSAs in Microsoft Advertising offer category targeting, letting advertisers direct their efforts towards specific website sections. This feature guarantees ads match user searches, enabling businesses to focus their advertising on high-value categories and optimize their budget usage.

Image Source

Parallels with Google

Many similarities exist between Microsoft's and Google's DSA solution. Both platforms generate ads from website content, provide category targeting, and utilize user searches for ad creation. These commonalities make the switch from Google's DSA to Microsoft's DSA smooth for advertisers.

It's noteworthy that Microsoft often follows Google's lead in advertising solutions. This pattern suggests that Microsoft might introduce a Performance Max (PMax) campaign equivalent in the future, reflecting Google's move towards giving advertisers greater control over their ad assets.

If this change happens, advertisers using Microsoft's DSA will need to adjust their approach to reap the benefits of PMax campaigns. These benefits may include greater control over ad assets, increased reach across multiple networks, and more conversion opportunities. Despite the transition requiring a more hands-on approach to ad creation, the improved performance and higher return on investment could make this shift beneficial for many advertisers.

The Marin Software Point of View

Proactively Transition to PMax

Though Google hasn't officially recommended moving from Dynamic Search Ads (DSA) to Performance Max (PMax) campaigns, the team here at Marin Software advocates for a proactive shift. PMax campaigns' popularity and advantages make them a promising addition to your advertising tactics. The broad reach of PMax across multiple Google networks and the enhanced control over ad assets can improve ad performance and increase return on investment.

Image Source

Growth Through PMax Testing

Advertisers should begin experimenting with PMax campaigns alongside existing DSA campaigns. This strategy lets you compare performance and make data-driven decisions. Running a few DSAs in PMax offers insights into this new campaign type’s advantages and challenges. It's crucial to monitor results, adapting strategies accordingly.

We are also encouraging advertisers to maintain their DSAs, particularly on Microsoft, while testing PMax campaigns. Microsoft's DSA solution, similar to Google's, remains a valuable tool in your advertising toolkit. Keeping DSAs active while testing PMax ensures you still benefit from DSAs.

Furthermore, advertisers should continue using exclusion URLs in their campaigns. Exclusion URLs stop your ads from appearing for specific website pages. This proves especially useful in PMax campaigns, where you can control ad assets more. Excluding irrelevant or low-performing pages lets you concentrate your advertising on high-value areas, optimizing ad targeting and enhancing campaign performance.

Adapting to Future Advertising Campaigns

If your team needs a hand on optimizing your ads across networks and strategies, the Marin team is here to help. Our MarinOne platform helps advertisers maximize ROI and ROAS across channels, making A/B testing and new ideas not only simple, but easy to implement and evaluate. To learn more about Marin Software or MarinOne, contact us here.

Gregory Pantaine & Coen Diepenhorst

By submitting this form, I am agreeing to Marin’s privacy policy.

See why brands have relied on Marin to manage over $48 billion in spend